Re-searching: non-expensive RFID long-range UHF reader with HID interface support.
This article briefly describes our experience on a project for warehouse inventory control where one of the components required where USB and Bluetooth readers working in UHF within 1-5 meters range (1 meter range is acceptable).
Problem
I was always excited by RFID technology, and always willing to work on projects from this field. Recently we’ve got a project. As part of warehouse management solution client wants an option to control inventory through RFID technology. The goal was to get a PC station with USB reader for check-in/checkout and mobile reader for cycle inventory count in warehouse. The solution is not complex, we did something similar few times with Motorola RFID readers.
I was sure the market should be going forward during last 2 years. Technology is evolving, everyone is mobile, hardware is cheaper and smaller, everyone has a computer in their pocket. There should be dozens of great and cheap Bluetooth (or at least USB) reader devices from multiple brands.
Surprise…
After 3 or 4 hours of searching, I’ve found only a few branded devices that might satisfy my expectations. But, unfortunately, they are either not cheap, or have no Android SDK or have small reading range.
For those interested, let me give you the results.
Device name | Declared reading range | Bluetooth, USB | Interface comments | Price | URL |
BlueBerry HS UHF from Tertium Technology | 30 cm | Bluetooth 2.1, USB | HID, SPP | $460 | Product details |
UHF-USB-HID-KEY from Id-EST | 50 cm | USB | Keyboard Wedge Emulation Reading Mode (HID only?) | ?? | Product details |
qIDmini (Model R1170I) from CaenRFID | 90 cm | Bluetooth 2.0, USB | HID, Apple compatibility available | $600 | Product details |
DIR120 from TSS company | 50 cm | USB | ? | ? | Product details |
IDBLUE.UHF from IDBlue | 2-4 cm | Bluetooth 2.0, USB | HID, SPP | $600 | Product details |
1128 Bluetooth® UHF RFID Reader from Technology Solutions, UK Ltd. | 4 m | Bluetooth 2.0 | HID, SPP | $1511 | Product details |
USB Plus+ RFID Reader from ThingMagic | 0.91 m | USB | SPP | $445 | Product details |
1126 Desktop UHF RFID Reader with USB | 1.5 m | USB | ? | $569 | Product details |
RFID ME™ USB Dongle from MTI and Mini Me | 30 cm | USB | HID, SPP | $200 | Product details, product specifications |
RFID ME: READ ME UHF RFID USB Desktop Reader | 1 m | USB | HID, SPP | $250 | Product details |
1861 RFID reader from CipherLab | 1 m | Bluetooth 2.1, USB | HID, SPP, but no Android SDK 🙁 | $651 | Product details |
Handheld RFID Reader AT288UHF from ATID | 5 m | Bluetooth 2.1, USB | HID, SPP | $651 | Product details |
That’s it. None of the found devices satisfied our initial goal of mobile reader: Bluetooth, price <$800, reading range >1 m, Android SDK available, HID support; although there is one very close (AT288 from ATID).
Also, several not expensive USB readers are present on the market and have good reading range.
Definitions
- Human interface device (HID) is a type of computer device that interacts directly with, and most often takes input from, humans and may deliver output to humans. The term “HID” most commonly refers to the USB-HID specification. The term was coined by Mike Van Flandern of Microsoft when he proposed the USB committee create a Human Input Device class working group.
- Bluetooth profile is a specification regarding an aspect of Bluetooth-based wireless communication between devices. It resides on top of the Bluetooth Core Specification and (optionally) additional protocols. In order to use Bluetooth technology, a device must be compatible with the subset of Bluetooth profiles necessary to use the desired services.
- Serial Port Profile (SPP) – this Bluetooth profile is based on ETSI 07.10 and the RFCOMM protocol. It emulates a serial cable to provide a simple substitute for existing RS-232, including the familiar control signals. It is the basis for DUN, FAX, HSP and AVRCP.SPP maximum payload capacity is 128 bytes.
- Ultra high frequency (UHF) is the ITU designation for radio frequencies in the range between 300 MHz and 3 GHz, also known as the decimetre band as the wavelengths range from one to ten decimetres. UHF radio waves propagate mainly by line of sight; they are blocked by hills and large buildings although the transmission through building walls is high enough for indoor reception.
- Keyboard wedge/PS2 – hardware plugged between the PC and its normal keyboard, with characters from the barcode scanner appearing exactly as if they had been typed at the keyboard.